The online news revolution
THORNBURG, R. 2011. Producing online news. Washington, DC: CQ Press
In response to the rise of online news and the present crisis within professional journalism, this textbook is a training manual specifically written for students of online journalism. It is a structured course covering various on-line journalistic skills and techniques such as editing, layout, headlines, articles, multimedia reporting and data use etc.
Of particular relevance for my essay is chapter 1 because this gives a useful overview of the current situation of online news, especially with regards to the increasing importance of the amateur journalist. Furthermore, online journalism is neatly assessed via the three pillars of "Multimedia" (including convergence/integration of multimedia), "Interactive" (the combining of journalists and the audience through discussion boards, forums, live chat, Facebook, Twitter and blogs etc) and "On-demand" (the flexible availability of news at anytime and anywhere due to laptops, mobile phones, ipods and hyperlinks etc). Also, in chapter 3 there are some useful, up-to-data statistics regarding the American online audience and chapter 11 contains good discussions on the importance of interactivity with the audience in 21st century journalism.
Throughout, there are many useful internet news articles/images and practical data in graphs, charts and tables. All information being up-to-data (2011) with the use of numerous real-life example and situations that the reader can relate to. Furthermore, technical terms are printed in bold text and are explained in straightforward English. The overall result is a book that is interesting, easy to read, relevant and informative.
MEIKLE, G. And G. REDDEN. (eds). 2011.News online. Britain: CPI Antony Rowe
Under the theme of "transformations and continues" this is an up-to-date (2011) assessment of the online news revolution and its impact upon professional journalism and all aspects of the news industry. Interestingly, the book analyzes an array of opinions, possible solutions and various outcomes through specialist chapters that deal with different particular issues.
In detailing the online development of BBC News, the first chapter gives us an excellent role model for success, especially with regards to interactivity. However, of particular importance for my essay is the second chapter because this specifically deals with the online news revolution in the UK. The present crisis of confidence in UK journalism is discussed and there is a focus on the future potential of professional journalism, especially with regards to amateur journalism and celebrity culture. Similarly, chapters 9,10 and 12 also assess the possible future outcomes for professional journalism, whether good, bad or in co-existence with amateur journalism.
The third chapter is interesting because it does not entirely blame the internet and the online revolution for the crisis in professional journalism. Rather the claim is made that problems already existed in the industry back in the 1980s and 1990s, such as cutbacks, bias and lack of trust. Whereas the fifth chapter looks at emerging "news games" and their future potential for online news.
In criticism, this book contains no diagrams, images, graphs or data etc. However it does address the main issues, is new, relevant and informative.
ALLAN, S. 2006. Online news. England: Open University Press
This is a book that examines the actual reporting of various incidents in recent history. The focus being upon the online news coverage of major events such as September 11, the 2003 invasion of Iraq, the London bombings and Hurricane Katrina etc.
Throughout the book, the author concentrates his attention upon the rising significance of the amateur journalist. He discusses their emergence, impact and relevance, whilst also identifying problem areas such as unreliable sources, liars and hoaxers. At the same time the author is highly critical of traditional "helicopter" journalism that does not give balance to the reality of catastrophic events.
Of special interest to my essay is the analysis of amateur journalism in offering first-hand accounts, mobile telephone footage, digital photographs and video recordings etc, combined with blogging and means of citizen news distribution.
On the negative side, the book was published in 2006 and therefore is already out-of-date in such a fast-moving industry. Hence its focus upon the emergence of amateur journalism, without offering practical solutions for the future of online news and not making useful forecasts that could be of real benefit. Furthermore there are no online images, diagrams, graphs or charts etc that would have given depth to the study.
Generally, the book gives us a useful snapshot of journalistic worries and concerns in 2006.
BOCZKOWSKI, P. 2005. Digitizing the News. New Baskerville: The MIT, Press
Boczkowski examines the historical development of online news in America from the 1980s and looks at how this development has evolved in order to yield insights into the construction products, and adoption of new media. He also analyzes the arrival of other new technologies in the the past, such as the invention of the press and the more recent use of facsimile, so as to attain various trends of behavior within the news industry.
Although the book is a little out-dated (2004-2005) Boczkowski is able to make some useful and accurate future predictions from his studies and surveys that are present throughout the various chapters. For example, he shows that those American dailies that would struggle on the web would be those who assumed it would bring an improved, but not drastically different, version of the present. When, infact, online news has become very different to the printed dailies. In addition, Boczkowski correctly identifies the dynamics of media convergence as an important "evolutionary" process for the development of online news, rather than it becoming a "revolutionary" process that drives all media into a common form. Furthermore, he shows that success for online paper is based upon limited alignment with the print newsroom, a flexible editorial function and respect for the public as being technically savvy.
In general, this book presents relevant analytical findings that focus attention upon the need for print papers to "contribute" to technical developments, rather than simply "reacting" to them.
SALWEN, M.B. GARRISON, B.And DRISCOLL, P.D., 2005.Online News and Public. New Jersey London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
This is a study of public and online news in America, based upon the analysis of various social surveys. Part 1 of the book is relevant for my essay because it assesses online news papers and online news trends, whereas part 2 of the book is mostly irrelevant since it focuses on online chats room. Although chapters 5 from parts 2 is useful as it looks at online news credibility.
Whilst the book's description of online news development from the 1980s will be mostly ignored, there are some other interesting points that are discussed in detail. For instance, it is mentioned that online newspapers do not want to compete against their print versions and lose readers, especially as there is little business sense in having separate online and print staff in competition. Rather, it is argued that online news would be most effective as a promotional vehicle for its more lucrative print versions. Indeed, the author sees this as the only option at present (2006) because of the lack of a successful economic model to emulate.
Generally, online newspapers struggle to generate profits and efforts to charge subscriptions for users have largely failed.
Interestingly there are some accurate future predictions, such as the increasing significance of media convergence, the need for new industry skills (working with text, images, audio and video etc) and likely concerns about the reliability of online news sources.
D'HAENENS, L., N. JANKOWSKI, AND A. HEUVELMAN. 2004 News in online and print newspapers: Differences in reader consumption and recall. journal of new media and society [online]. **6(3), [Accessed 28 April 2011] pp.363-381. Available from: http://nms.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/6/3/363
This journal was written at a time (2004) of widespread redundancies within journalism as well as cutbacks and a general atmosphere of uncertainty throughout the news industry. Therefore this study is relevant for my essay because it give insights from a recent past when many feared that printed news was soon to become obsolete. In particular, the research specifically assesses the ability of readers to consume, retain and news from both online and offline sources.
Carried out in response to a study by Tewksbury and Althaus ( that readers of online news are unable to understand and recall news as efficiently as readers of printed news) this experiment by Haenes, Jankwski and Heuvelman was made of the online and print versions of two newspapers in the Netherlands.
Brief and concise, this journal contains many good graphs and tables of data in order to give clarity to the overall findings. The concluding evidence showing that online readers do not consume and retain news differently from readers of the print versions. This having been a thorough survey of 151 participants who were asked to recall news stories they had read (online and offline) one week earlier.
To sum up, this experiment will be mentioned in my essay because it supports the idea of compatibility between online and offline news, rather than the concept of one or the other. Mention is also made of the future need to investigate the pleasure, or lack of, that readers experience whilst reading news, whether online or offline.
AHLERS, D. 2006. News consumption and the new electronic media. The Harvard International Journal Of Press/Politics [Online]. **11(1), [Accessed 29 April 2011], pp. 29-48. Available from: http://hij.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/11/1/29**
Similar to the previous journal, this American survey was also written at s time of growing apprehension and uncertainty within a print and television news media that was now facing a rapid increase in the expansion of online news (2006). In particular this study sought to analyse prediction of the demise of the traditional news media through its detailed and comprehensive set of surveys.
The author notes that we would normally expect a shift to new technology within the workings of a perfect market. That is, in a way similar to how the banks pushed their customers towards using ATMs and online banking, so we should be able to predict the abandoning of the traditional news media by both producers and users in favour of the lower cost/lower price alternative of online news. However, the findings showed that there was only 12% direct substation from offline to online news consumption. Furthermore, two-thirds of the US adult populations have not migrated to the consumption of online news.
Although this article is a little out-dated (2006) it is useful because it does show that the traditional news media is not about to collapse. Rather, a close analysis of the data shows that the majority of online news consumers use it as a complement to the traditional news media and not as a substitute. As of 2006, only small group are actually substituting offline news for online news.
MARCUS, J. AND RICE, X. 2011. Medialens's website [Online]. [Accessed 15 April 2011]. Available from: http://www.medialens.org/
At the heart of today's debate regarding the future of online and offline news is the controversial issue of amateur journalists, sometimes known as citizen journalists. Therefore this UK website is of particular interest in this regard because it has been formulated by people who are not employed by the professional news media. The site has existed since 2001 and claims to concentrate mainly on responding to questions from its readers, many of whom are said to be undergraduate and postgraduate students.
As a challenger to mainstream media, this site is highly critical of traditional news whom it accuses of bias, lies and propaganda in their reporting of national and international affairs. Therefore it is interesting to read the site;s articles on issues such as the civilian casualty figures in Iraq, dictatorship in Yemen, the war in Libya, the "tyranny" of corporate media monopoly and wikileaks etc. Interestingly, although the site approaches such that this of unrestricted, unanswerable coverage of events can lead to extremist or incorrect conclusions that may appear to the general public as fair, balanced reporting.
In general, these types of amateur journalists cannot be ignored from my essay because of their increasing significance, especially when websites such as this are very professional in appearance and contain links for forum, message board, Facebook, Twitter and YouTube. In other words, they are technology savvy and expanding.
Online news and multimedia have revoulutionised journalism and the news industry in recent years. Therefore, it is the purpose of this essay to examine this revolution, to assess its impact and to consider possible future outcomes. There will also be a short conclusion with a summary of the main points.
The impact of online news and multimedia upon the news industry has been significant in the past 15 years or so. Indeed, some analysts have even described developments as causing a "revolution" and a "crisis of confidence" within professional journalism, as well as generating widespread redundancies ana a "financial crisis" too. (Mcnair, pp.38-39, 2001). In the past, the reporting via traditional media, such as TV and printed newspapers, was one-directional from the source to the reporter and then onto the audience. However this traditional approach is now being challenged by an interactive audience that is able to contribute to the reporting, commentary and spreading of news via Email, Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Blogs/Forums, links between websites and comments on articles. (Thornburg, 2001).
Online news and multimedia have also generated other challenges for professional journalism. For example, by ending the one-way flow of news, the interactivity of the Web now compels reporters to answer questions from their audience and so involve them in the reporting process. Elsewhere, "politicians, businesspeople and celebrities are new speaking directly to the audience, without a reporter as an intermediary". (Thornburg, 2011, pp.306-307).
However, of particular concern to professional journalism has been the emergence of "amateur" journalists, also Known as "citizen" journalists, those individuals who gather information and post it on the Web with their own commentary. In this book, Allan (2006, p.7) praises citizen journalism as "…….the extraordinary contribution made by ordinary citizens offering their first-hand reports, digital photographs, camcorder video footage, mobile telephone snapshots or audio clips". In other words, Allan ses them as providing a realistic counter-balance to out-of-touch "helicopter journalism". (Allan, 2006. p.7). Similarly, Mcnair (2001, p.44) defends the spread of citizen journalism by highlighting the "bias" and the lack of "trust" that is often associated with mainstream journalism.
Traditional media is also threatened by the fact the online news is available 24 hour a day and 7 days a week. Search tools information to be easily picked out and there is a vast archive to choose from because the storing of digital information is very cheap. Importantly, however, this availability of online news can now be accessed in virtually any location due to mobile phones, laptops, ipods, smart phones and ipads. (Thornburg, 2001).
Therefore the ongoing impact of online news has caused much concern across the news industry, leading some researchers to examine various aspects of online news and traditional media compatibility. For example, Dhanenes, Jankowski and Heuvelman (2004) carried out an experimental study that concluded that readers of print news do not consume and retain news differently to readers of online news. also, Ahlers (2006) showed that two-thirds of the adult population in America have not substituted online news for traditional news media. Rather, online news acts as a complement to traditional news media.
Interestingly, Boczkowski (2005, p.13) criticizes American dailies for assuming "that the future (of online news) would be an improved but not radically different, version of the present", whereas online news has in fact become very different to printed news. He also claims that the news industry has not been as innovativa as those competitors who are less tied to traditional media. In other words, print papers have tended to react to developments online rather than contribute to them because their priority has been to protect printed news, even if this is at the expense of promoting online media. They "emphasize smaller but more certain shorter-term gains rather than potentially larger, but less certain, longer-term benefits". (Boczkowski, 2005. p.171).
Furthermore, Boczkowski (2005) also examines different theories of "convergence" (multimedia integration) and claims that most of these theories assume that he "revolutionary effects of new technology will lead all media to convergence into a common end form. Whereas he has actually identified convergence as being an ongoing "evolutionary" process of merging the Web's new possibilities with established old ways.
Therefore, if we take a fresh and neutral look at the impact of online news and multimedia upon the news industry, we discover that negative future predictions are premature and unreliable. For example, whilst online news may now have overtaken printed news in terms of popular use, most multimedia users are only from the minority of young, white and middle class. (Thornburg, 2001).
Furthermore, the emergence of citizen journalists does not mean the inevitable demise of professional journalism. Amateur reporting can be very unreliable due to conspiracy theories, lies, forgery, rumours, gossip and hoaxes. (Allan, 2006). In addition, it is also noted by Mcnair (2011, p.48) that citizen journalism is "often angry, abusive, racist, and to be handled in ways that did not cause undue offence". Indeed, (medialens.org) is typical of citizen journalism. It deals with controversial issues (Iraq, Libya etc) with a slick website that has links to Facebook and YouTube etc. Yet it could be described as extreme in its accusations, whilst being accountable to no one.
Overall, whilst amateur journalists can counter the perceived bais of mainstream media, professional are needed in the industry because they analyse events with resources, time and experience, rather than simply recycling what other are reporting (as is the case with much social networking and amateur journalism). (Mcnair, 2001).Therefore this would suggest that both professional and amateur journalism are actually complementary to one another.
Co-existence is also mentioned by Salwen, M>G>D (2005) who states that online newspapers would be most effective as tools to promote their more Lucrative print versions. He also believes that there is no business sense in online newspapers competing with their own print versions and so lose readers. Garrison (2005) also makes the point that online newspapers are nowhere near making sufficient profits to replace printed newspapers. In addition, efforts at subscriptions for online news have largely failed. (Macnair, 2011).
In terms of examples, the BBC can be cited as a successful model for online news (especially audience interactivity) and traditional news compatibility. (Melkle and Redden, 2011). Other early adopters and investors of online news, such as the Guardian, the Financial Times and the Telegraph, have also maintained very successful compatibility (Macnair, 2011).
Therefore the challenge for professional journalism is to adapt to the online revolution and, in this respect, news games are a possibility. (Melkle and Redden, 2011). Thornburg (2011) also mentions journalists websites that allow visitors to write stories, the adapting of news headlines and pictures for different screen dimensions and the importance of audience interactivity such as journalists joining conversations on the Web.
In conclusion, the revolution of online news is driven by the growing importance of multimedia integration, audience interactivity and the availability of news anytime and (almost) anywhere. However, as discussed, there is also scope for online news and printed news compatibility, as well as citizen journalism and professional journalism co-existence.
The future of the news industry depends upon the ability of traditional media to adapt in areas such as the pooling of online expertise between different organization, developing strategies to make online news financially lucrative and countering the "digital divide" of multimedia users and non-users.
ALLAN, S. 2006. Online news. England: Open University Press
BOCZKOWSKI, P. 2005. Digitizing the News. New Baskerville: The MIT,
GARRISON, B. 2005. Online newspaper. In: M.B. SALWEN, B. GARRISON,
and P.D. DRISCOLL, eds. Online News and Public. New Jersey
London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, pp.742
MCNAIR, B. 2011. Managing the online news revolution: the UK
Experience. In: G. MEIKLE and G. REDDEN, eds. News online. Britain: CPI
Antony Rowe, pp.38-39-44-47-48
MEIKLE, G. and REDDEN, G. 2011. Introduction: transformation and continuity. In: G. MEIKLE and G. REDDEN, eds. News online. Britain: CPI
Antony Rowe, pp.2-5-6-8
SALWEN, M.B. GARRISON, B. and DRISCOLL, P.D. 2005.Public fear of
terrorism and the news media. In: M.B. SALWEN, B. GARRISON,
and P.D. DRISCOLL, eds. Online News and Public. New Jersey
London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, pp.6119
THORNBURG, R. 2011. Producing online news. Washington, DC: CQ Press
AHLERS, D. 2006. News consumption and the new electronic media. The Harvard International Journal Of Press/Politics [Online]. 11(1), [Accessed 29 April 2011], pp. 29-48. Available from:http://hij.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/11/1/29
D'HAENENS, L., N. JANKOWSKI, AND A. HEUVELMAN. 2004 News in online and print newspapers: Differences in reader consumption and recall. journal of new media and society [online]. 6(3), [Accessed 28 April 2011] pp.363-381. Available from: http://nms.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/6/3/363
MARCUS, J. AND RICE, X. 2011. Medialens's website [Online]. [Accessed 15 April 2011]. Available from:http://www.medialens.org/
MUHSEN ALQARNI 1030905
The Online News Revolution
The online news revolution has Trans formed traditional media to a journalistic hybrid as they combine the best of traditional and web. In recent years, we have witnessed an influx of wikis, blogs and many amateur news websites that have caused panic in the mainstream media. The traditional media in journalism have been criticized for their bias, cutbacks and lack of trust. Online news has been criticized due to their unreliable sources, hoaxers and liars. Traditional journalism has always overlooked some details when reporting catastrophic events. Amateur journalists have broken news that most professional organizations have refused to break. Amateur journalism has been in filtrating the media at a very shocking rate. Through the Internet, people access news from all over the world at their own discretion (Allan, 2006).
We have witnessed blogs and amateur websites providing more participation, rationality, immediacy and customization than traditional newspapers and TV. Since efforts to charge subscribers have failed, most online newspapers are struggling to make profits. Modern journalism must ensure compatibility between the offline and online news. In the long term, we are likely to see a shift from traditional news media to the lower cost online news. We should always remember technology changes every day and online publishing can be unreliable (D'Haenens, Jankowski and Heuvelman, 2004).
Allan, S. 2006. Online news. England: Open University Press.
D'Haenens, L., Jankowski, N. and Heuvelman, A. 2004. News in online and print newspapers: Differences in reader consumption and recall. journal of new media and society 6(3), pp.363-381. [Online] Available at: http://nms.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/6/3/363 [Accessed 28 April 2011].
Hope Ogbologugo (1031983)
The news industry has certainly not been left out in the revolution of the internet. Although personally I have a given a passing thought to how more and more, individuals turn to the internet for news consumption, I did not think it out thoroughly until I read your article. It is somewhat of an irony that an organization, in this case, a newspaper house, would be in competition, not with another media house but with itself! The print Vs. the online version.
You made mention that the challenge for professional journalism is to adapt to the online revolution, while this may be true, there are however implications of this adaptation. For instance, to what extent can a private citizen be protected by law if a traditional news organization uses the individual as a source and legal issues arise?
Furthermore, with the rise in the activities of citizen journalists, copyright issues crop up and with the nature of the internet, this is one legal issue which is at best largely undefined and uncharted.
Rappaport, A. J. and Leith, A. M. (2007) ‘Brave New World? Legal Issues Raised by Citizen Journalism’, Communications Lawyer, 25(2) pp.1-38, EBSCOhost [Online] Available at: http://0-web.ebscohost.com.brum.beds.ac.uk/ehost/detail?sid=3a3a4860-6827-4db0-875a-427b1cdf1375%40sessionmgr113&vid=4&hid=122&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZSZzY29wZT1zaXRl#db=ufh&AN=28458852 (Accessed: 29 May 2011)
Qamar sheraz 1023309
online sources are one of the easy and quick way to get the current news in the world and at the national level
Xiaoqi Wang 1023231
Comment On The online news revolution
This essay makes a general introduction and analysis ofthe online news revolution. Also, the article talked about the impact and the potential trend in the future.
In recent years, with the rapid development of the network and the spring up of new media, the the old news spread approach has great changed. In the follow context, he compared the traditional media and the new media from their characteristics and professionals' different attitude to each of them.
As a new network communication way ,which emerged along with the new media, including websites such as Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Blogs…begin to come into masses' eyes. As a result,the traditional media, mainly including TV, book, magazine,newspaper, have faced severe challenge. The traditional news spread pattern is from source to the reporter then to audience. Different from the old media, the new media can be created by netizens then everyone can take part in the process of releasing and sharing the news quickly on the Internet and play an increasing important role.
Although many professionals strongly disagreed with the new emergence of citizen journalists, it is no doubt that with the evolution and the widely use of websites, the Internet is becoming one of the most important way for information spreading.Furthermore, beneficial to the booming of network and multimedia technology, the Internet has promoted the development of professional journalism industry.
In conclusion, the emergence of online news is not just in a burst of revolutionary technological change but by merging the structures and practices of existing media with newly available technical capabilities. (DIGITIZING THE NEWS Innovation in Online Newspaper by Pabol J. Boczkowski , in 2005)
Digitizing the News: Innovation in Online Newspapers
Author :Pabol J. Boczkowski in 2005